Why chocolate chips hold their shape and a chopped bar doesn't (quite)
Chocolate chips are formulated with slightly less cocoa butter and added stabilizers specifically so they keep their shape in the oven instead of melting completely into the batter — that's why chocolate chip cookies have distinct pockets of chocolate rather than chocolate swirled throughout. A chopped chocolate bar doesn't have those stabilizers, so it melts a bit more freely, giving slightly more spread and gooier pockets rather than hold-their-shape chunks. It's a very close substitute in flavor and still gives great results — just a marginally different texture.
When to reach for cocoa powder instead
Cocoa powder isn't a texture match for chips at all — there's no chunk or chip to bite into, since it's whisked directly into the batter with a little sugar and melted butter to restore the fat and sweetness a real chocolate would have brought. This works well when you want an overall richer, more chocolatey batter (think a brownie-style cookie) rather than pockets of melted chocolate throughout. It's the better move when you're completely out of any bar or chip chocolate, not a preferred choice when you do have one on hand.
Choosing the type of chocolate
In the US, semisweet and bittersweet chocolate must both contain at least 35% cocoa solids; bittersweet is usually less sweet and more intense, while semisweet is the standard chip. Milk chocolate is sweeter and softer, and white chocolate contains cocoa butter but no cocoa solids, so it brings sweetness and creaminess rather than chocolate flavor. If you swap one for another, measure by weight, and expect to notice the difference in flavor: bittersweet makes a less sweet cookie, milk chocolate a sweeter and slightly softer one.
Chopping a bar
Use a serrated knife to chop a bar, which grips the surface better than a smooth blade, and cut it into pieces roughly the size of a large chip. The fine shavings that fall away are not waste: they melt into the dough and create the marbled look many bakers like. As a guide, a 4-ounce bar is 113 g, and 170 g (6 ounces) is about 1 cup of chips. Chilling the dough for 30 minutes or more after mixing in chopped chocolate helps the cookies spread less and keeps the pieces in distinct pockets.
What not to use
Candy melts and melting wafers are made with vegetable fat in place of cocoa butter, and they melt and set differently from real chocolate, so they are a poor swap for baking chips. Chocolate with a high cocoa percentage (above about 80%) is bitter enough to need extra sugar in the recipe, so check the label before using it in place of semisweet chips.
FAQ
Can I use chocolate chunks or chocolate bark instead of chips? Yes, as an easy 1:1 swap by cup — both behave similarly to a chopped bar, melting a bit more than standard chips but still giving distinct pieces of chocolate throughout.
Does the cocoa version work for no-bake recipes? Not well — the melted butter and sugar mixture is designed to bake into the batter, not set up on its own the way real chocolate does once it cools, so no-bake recipes are better off with real chocolate.